Daimler loses - Greek court rules in favor of Chinese smart fortwo clone
Justice is blind
By Michael Gauthier
May 27, 2009 5:57 PM
Filed Under: Corporate/Financial, Design, European, Industry, Smart
There's an old saying that "justice is blind," an adage which has taken a literal meaning thanks to a Greek court's decision to dismiss Daimler's lawsuit against a Chinese copy of the Smart fortwo.
This effectively ends a long legal battle which started when Daimler blocked Shuanghuan from displaying the Noble at the Bologna Motor Show in 2007. Although the car was later allowed to go on sale in Europe in early 2008, Daimler kept up the pressure which resulted in Shuanghuan marketing the Noble under the slogan "Smarter than the rest".
The Greek court determined that "an informed buyer would not confuse the Noble with the Smart Fortwo." They also stated that because the two vehicles offer different technical specifications, any exterior styling similarities are irrelevant and almost inevitable because they're both mini-cars.
While many of us are likely to label the court's decision as ludicrous, it follows similar legal precedents set in other European court battles against an onslaught of Chinese clones.
Thankfully, many of the Chinese copies that eventually reach European markets typically fare poorly as consumers balk at their horrid questionable safety, quality and dismal reliability.
Related Articles
Comments
It has to do with the fact that it's a blatant copy. It's not impossible to make a similar car that is distinguishable. Toyata did with the IQ.
Edited by user on May 27, 2009 at 9:08 PM
My view on this is simple. European car manufacturers are now forced to up their game. All the better for us consumers who at times have to put up with over-priced cars.
Edited by user on May 28, 2009 at 11:36 AM
It is a basic conflict in our planet even in accord with Bible.
Edited by user on May 28, 2009 at 12:17 PM
Add Comment
- BMW 7 Series M Sport Receives Matt Black Trim Treatment by EAS
- Stig Approved: Caterham Superlight R500 – for £19.50
- Mercedes' AMG Division Considering Diesel?
- Bentley Unveils World’s Most Luxurious Charity Bus
- Porsche Cayman X-Wide by XTR Carchip
- 2011 Mercedes C-Class Facelift Latest Spy Photos
- Superchips Golf GTi MkVI ECU Remap Adds 44bhp
- Try outrunning this! F999 Police Car Unveiled
Latest F1 News
BMW Announce Deal to Sell F1 Team to Peter Sauber
Nov 27, 09 4:30 PM
Alonso works hard to win Ferrari 'confidence'
Nov 27, 09 4:00 PM
Canada GP return to be announced on Friday
Nov 27, 09 4:00 PM
Force India retains Sutil, Liuzzi
Nov 27, 09 4:00 PM
Ecclestone denies reviving Donington GP bid
Nov 27, 09 4:00 PM
Toro Rosso seat for Hartley possible - brother
Nov 27, 09 4:00 PM
American investors to rescue Sauber - report
Nov 26, 09 8:00 PM
Conway, Ericsson to test for Brawn at Jerez
Nov 26, 09 7:00 PM
Hamilton not worried by McLaren-Mercedes split
Nov 26, 09 6:30 PM
Wolff reveals rejected Williams investors
Nov 26, 09 6:00 PM

















hahahahahahaha...