Fiesta, IQ & Golf Battle for 2009 World Car of the Year Award

2009 World Car of the Year Finalists

Winner will be announced at the New York Auto Show

By Michael Gauthier
March 13, 2009 9:19 PM
Filed Under: Awards

The field of contestants up for the 2009 World Car of the Year Award has narrowed to three models, the Ford Fiesta, Toyota iQ, and Volkswagen Golf VI. Originally 51 vehicles were up for the prestigious award but after several rounds of voting, these three models ended up coming out on top.

Three other award categories also make up the annual World Car awards with each one representing a specific area of excellence. Finalists for the 2009 World Performance Car include the Corvette ZR1, Nissan GT-R, and Porsche 911 Carrera. The 2009 World Green Car award will go to the Honda FCX Clarity, Mitsubishi iMiEV, or the Toyota iQ. Among the stylish models competing for the design of the year award is the Citroen C5 Sedan / C5 Tourer, Fiat 500, and the Jaguar XF.

In order to determine who will walk away with the awards, a jury of 59 automotive journalists vote for the vehicle they consider to be the best in each category.

 

Source: wcoty

Press Release (Click to expand)

The countdown continues in preparation for the 2009 World Car Awards winners' press conference at the New York International Auto Show on Thursday, April 9, 2009.   Announcing the annual World Car of the Year awards at the New York show is a fitting finale to the international auto show season that begins each fall with either the Paris or Frankfurt motor shows.

 

From an initial entry list of fifty-one (51) new vehicles from all over the world, then a short list of ten finalists, the top three contenders for the overall 2009 World Car title were announced today by the international accounting firm KPMG.  They are, in alphabetical order:

  • Ford Fiesta
  • Toyota iQ
  • Volkswagen Golf VI         

To be eligible for the overall World Car award, the contender had to be in production, and sold, on at least two continents during 2008.

 

Vehicles are selected and voted on by an international jury panel comprised of fifty-nine (59) top-level automotive journalists from twenty-five (25) countries around the world.  Each juror was appointed by the World Car Steering Committee on the basis of his or her expertise, experience, credibility, and influence.  Each juror typically drives and evaluates new vehicles on a regular basis as part of their professional work.  

 

Three additional winners for the World Performance Car, World Green Car award, and the World Car Design of the Year will also be announced at the New York International Auto Show on Thursday, April 9, 2009.

 

In preparation, KPMG announced today that the Top Three finalists for the 2009 World Performance Car award, presented by Mobil 1, are, in alphabetical order:

  • Corvette ZR1
  • Nissan GT-R
  • Porsche 911 Carrera

While the winner of the overall World Car award must excel in a broad range of attributes, the World Performance Car award must demonstrate a specific and overt sports/performance orientation while satisfying the same availability criteria as for the overall World Car of the Year award.

 

Entrants may be chosen from that list of eligible vehicles, or they may be newly introduced variants that satisfy the same criteria, but are derived from existing rather than brand-new models. In all cases, they must have a minimum annual production rate of five-hundred (500) vehicles.

 

For more than 30 years, Mobil 1 engineering teams have been at the forefront of evolving engine technologies and design, collaborating with many of the world's leading automotive manufacturers," said Nancy Carlson, strategic global alliances - sales director, ExxonMobil Lubricants & Specialties. "Our teams have worked to ensure that Mobil 1 fully synthetic motor oil continues to deliver outstanding protection and performance benefits required for today's advanced engines. As the returning sponsor of the World Performance Car Award, we are pleased to be involved in recognizing the top performance cars of 2009 from this year's very impressive group of nominees.  We wish them all the best o f luck."

 

To be eligible for the 2009 World Green Car* award, a vehicle had to available in at least one major market during 2008. The vehicle or the green technology could be in production or an experimental prototype with potential near-future application, provided that it was released for individual or press fleet evaluations in quantities of ten or more during 2008.  Tailpipe emissions, fuel consumption, and use of a major advanced power plant technology (beyond engine componentry), aimed specifically at increasing the vehicle's environmental responsibility, were all taken into consideration.

 

Due to the complexity of some of the 'green' technologies, three (3) green experts were appointed by the World Car Steering Committee to extensively review all documentation and specs associated with each candidate.   They were asked to create a short-list of five finalists for review by the fifty-nine (59) jurors in their second round of voting in February.

 

The three green experts were in alphabetical order:

 

Sam Abuelsamid (representing North America) is the technical editor of several 'green' web sites including GreenFuelsForecast.com, DieselForecast.com and HydrogenForecast.com.  In 2006, he began writing for AutoblogGreen.com and Autoblog.com; becoming a full-time writer and photographer and editor in 2007.

 

Dean Slavnich (representing Europe) is editor of Engine Technology International (ETi) and its sister publication, Electric & Hybrid Vehicle Technology International (E&H), for the past four years.  Engine Technology International is widely regarded as the most readable, passionate and informative publication currently produced on the subject of OE engine and powertrain design, development and manufacture.

 

Tadashi Tateuchi (representing Asia) is the creator and chairman of the Japan Electric Vehicle (EV) Club.  He was awarded the Environment Minister's medal in 1998.  A juror on the Japan Car of the Year panel, he contributes regularly to Car Graphic magazine and the Japan Automobile Federation's monthly magazine. 

 

The fifty-nine (59) member jury chose the following top three finalists for the 2009 World Green Car award:

  • Honda FCX Clarity
  • Mitsubishi iMiEV
  • Toyota iQ

Cars eligible for the 2009 World Car Design of the Year award are taken from the list of World Car candidates.

 

A design panel consisting of four highly respected world design experts was asked to first review each candidate, and then establish a short-list of recommendations for the jurors.  The design experts were:    

  • Silvia Baruffaldi: Managing Editor, Auto & Design magazine
  • Robert Cumberford:  design critic, Automobile and Auto & Design magazines
  • Akira Fujimoto:  Editor-in-Chief, Car Styling magazine.
  • Tom Matano: Executive Director, School of Industrial Design, Academy of Art University, San Francisco, USA

Jurors then voted on the experts' recommendations. The top three design finalists are, in alphabetical order:

  • Citroen C5 Sedan / C5 Tourer
  • Fiat 500
  • Jaguar XF     

Now in their sixth year, the annual World Car awards have become one of the most prestigious, significant, and credible programs of their type in the world.

 

The awards were inaugurated in 2003, and officially launched in January 2004, to reflect the reality of the global marketplace, as well as to recognize and reward automotive excellence on a global scale.   The awards are intended to complement, not compete, with existing national and regional Car of the Year programs.

 

The awards are administered by a non-profit association, under the guidance of a Steering Committee of pre-eminent automotive journalists from Asia, Europe, and North America.  There is no affiliation with, nor are the awards in any way influenced by any publication, auto show, automaker, or other commercial enterprise.

Comments

ShinyG
March 13, 2009 11:16 PM
I voted Fiesta because I like it, but I think the Golf will win! VW is a master of building mundane cars that sell by the boatloads. They call it "marketing a product to the masses". I call it "selling to the peasants" or "bland sells better than hotcakes"!

ADJ-117
March 15, 2009 12:10 AM
There are some big flaws in your logic. If VW simply market for the "peasants" then why is it typically more expensive (albeit not by a lot) than many of its competitors? Also, it just so happens to be a good car as it is, so if it's working well for them then why would they change it, why would they try and be all fancy with unnecessary measures if what they already have works so well. Same logic goes behind the Porsche 911's, and surely you won't say those are just being marketed to the masses too?

It seems a lot more like you are biased against the VW, towards the Ford, or both. I mean if anything, it is the Fiesta which is marketed for the peasants as it is the more affordable small car that they're trying to give everything. Hell it isn't even that small any more.

Joe_Limon
March 15, 2009 5:31 AM
no, he is right, vw's "low ego emissions" campaign said it all. They are selling cars that you can feel good about buying without sticking out. But if you are buying a car for that reason, I believe you are being way to self conscious about your image. [edit]It's like dating an average looking girl with a good heart and turning down a good looking girl with a good heart, just because the good looking girl may fall into a bad stereotype.


Edited by user on March 15, 2009 at 5:34 AM
kmayb
March 13, 2009 11:36 PM
I must say that the iQ has to be the winner based on the fact that Toyota have created a truly revolutionary vehicle that has some amazing packaging technology such as fuel tank design and layout, reddesigned power steering mechanism, seating arrangements and even compact A/C Systems. The fact that it is a car as small as the Smart but offers seating for four truely reflects what the world needs at the moment in our more congested, polluted cities. The other two are simply evolution on existing platforms. I'm sure they are good cars but they require no more sophisticated design than the models they replace.

trinity
March 15, 2009 6:08 PM
I fully agree with you. The fiesta and the golf dont bring anything really new, while the iQ is revolutionary.

Joe_Limon
March 14, 2009 6:16 AM
world car of the year or world compact car of the year? As far as styling goes the fiesta annihilates the toyota, and is mildly ahead of the vw.

Michael
March 14, 2009 7:31 AM
Golf VI for comfort and driveability, Fiesta for exterior design, and IQ for being in line with these times (requiring smaller cars).

BabyMilo
March 14, 2009 11:51 AM
I voted fiesta. I think that the other two are nice cars, but the fiesta is just abit more funky and cool. The VW is abit boring and like the old model and the IQ just isnt as cool as the Fiesta.

Get_real
March 15, 2009 1:14 PM
Should be the iQ, that one is innovative, Golf and Fiesta are not bringing anything really new. I think the reason why it won't do well in WCF's poll is just because it's a Toyota.

Homerlovesbeer
March 16, 2009 6:34 AM
The golf is pretty boring having just driven the TSI just last week .Yes it's nice but it hasn't moved on since the last gen model which really dissapointed me.

The fiesta is cheeky and funky, misses out on hardly anything the golf has perhaps satnav and auto parking, and is light and fun to drive.

The IQ is very cool too but i'm not sure it is world car of the year material as it just doesn't work in some countries (USA and Australia to name a couple.)

Golf last then with Fiesta first IMO.


Edited by user on March 16, 2009 at 6:35 AM
View Comment Rules

Add Comment

You are modifying your comment

Exisiting User

Username
Password
remember me

New Users

Username
Email
Password
Comment

Your account

username
password

Other links