WCF Test Drive: Porsche Carrera 4S

 WCF Test Drive: Porsche Carrera 4S
Porsche Carrera 4S

Best every-day-car in the world

Best every-day-car in the world

It was the journey back from our epic voyage that truly proved the strengths of the Porsche Carrera 4S as perhaps the ultimate every day car in its social weight class. With torrential rain falling sideways from the sky the dependable Porsche ploughed a constant furrow through Belgium to the welcoming sight of a P&O Ferry at Calais and carried us to a safe journey home after 2500 miles at the wheel.

The child within says that the GT3 is more fun, but it comes with in-built consequence. The lightweight RS-model two rows behind us at the ferry port had just made it into France when their road rocket spun at a roundabout and buried them in a wall. While they limped back to Britain with a chunk of wheel rubbing against the tyre and the wing hanging off to return the car to the driving club from whence it came, the 4S never put a foot wrong.

And we asked a lot of our steed as we hunted for a de-restricted Autobahn to truly unleash the full 355bhp and chase the horizon like bloodthirsty devil dogs. With the environmentalists looking hard at the lack of German speed limits as a contributing factor to global warming and European laws homogenising over time then there is little hope for the Autobahn’s future.

The days of howling down the left-lane at whatever speed your steed will carry you are limited, so we had to enjoy it one last time, preferably behind the wheel of a Porsche. The Carrera 4S is as dependable as the 911 line-up gets, but with 0-60mph time of 4.8s and a top end speed of 179mph it’s plenty quick off the mark.

So, with our weapon of choice, we set off in earnest to celebrate the Autobahn before it’s taken away. Even if going fast hadn’t been part of the brief, the Porsche would have stretched its legs every single time the distinctive de-restriction signs came forth. This car offers an addictive slug of acceleration and doesn’t even need a change down the six-speed box to access the huge spread of torque. As it has just 295lb/ft on offer, Porsche has clearly worked wonders with the spread.

The 3.8-litre flat six engine positioned over the rear wheels is normally aspirated in the Carrera range and benefits from four decades of development on road and track. It is without doubt one of the finest powerplants in the world and should by rights take its place in engineering folklore. Basically it’s in the wrong place, hung out the back in total defiance of the laws of Physics.

Yet with years of practice and the advance of electronic technology Porsche has managed to create a car that it’s almost impossible to spin and takes almost no skill to drive fast. Time and again we were shocked as the car took just fingertip control at speeds of more than 140mph.

The wind roared its protest as the car cut a swathe, other cars flew back at video game speeds and the flat six found its voice in the latter half of the rev range as the scenerymelted outside the window. Yet contained within the plush seats, the car felt like the eye of the storm from the inside. It was unhurried, unruffled, stately even, and proved just how far the 911 has come from its blaring air-cooled days. Yet the car fed back the road surface as if it were brushing a hand across the tarmac.

I’d want the rear-drive only Carrera 2, rather than the four-wheel drive, but the general Porsche customer will hardly ever push this car hard enough to engage that viscous coupling and send the power to the front wheels.

Thrown into bends it retains the rear drive attitude until things are out of hand, at which point the average banker that has punted their bonus on a fast car will be delighted that it has found a way to stop them crashing. Sadly it means that when pushed beyond the limit this car will plough into understeer and you’ll have to provoke it with a pointy stick to push the rear out in a major way. It can be done, but it’s almost harder than crashing the car, which is almost impossible in itself.

At speed it’s even better, caressing the apex like a vice nuzzles against a grape. It is so utterly refined at speeds that would blow the engine of lesser machines it’s hard to imagine how they could improve upon the base 911. They have, of course, the Turbo is the absolute pinnacle of relaxed, rocket ship transport, but then that commands serious premium over the £71,980 Carrera 4S.

The Carrera is much less blinged-up than the ever so slightly overdressed Turbo, too, with those LED indicators in the front end banished along with the hamster cheek spotlights. The Carrera’s front end offers a much simpler, more elegant and more Porsche-like look to proceedings and its naturally muscular flanks look just fine without a bi-plane rear wing. This is the core shape that has evolved over 40 years of 911 production and arguably the most resolved and fluid looking deign in the line-up.

The Turbo is the ultimate everyday supercar, but then you’ve still got to be seriously wedged up to cover the fuel bills, insurance and basic purchase price. The Carrera 4S is still on the expensive side, but it’s just about the best every day car in the world for the money and anyone that disagrees would do well to point out the alternatives.

Add a Comment

Comments (19)

Subscribe to comments
 Harajoshi Harajoshi
Best car, I would agree with you, but must be a real four-seater. For me, as a rich man, I'd for the Panamera.
November 16, 2007 2:27 pm
 Harajoshi Harajoshi
it must...
November 16, 2007 2:28 pm
 Aris_C Aris_C
I would vote for the 997 turbo as the best everyday car. Comfortable, fast, prestige, 4 seater and of course expensive. Dont forget the 0-160-0 where it comes first in line! This is all around performance
November 16, 2007 2:38 pm
 peccles peccles
The 2008 Chevrolet Corvette Base and Z06 are the best everyday sports cars for the money.
November 16, 2007 4:04 pm
 FOXHOUND FOXHOUND
oh no you should'nt of said that peccles, now there is going to be like 10,000 comments of people fighting with each other about wich is better and you know some of the german readers and their racially biast mindsets are gonna try to tear you apart. personally i would take either car(corvette z06/porsche c4s), they're both very nice.
November 16, 2007 5:35 pm
 peccles peccles
The Carerra 4S does have slightly better handling, slightly better steering feel, better manual gearbox, and better fit/finish than both Corvettes. It should for the money Porsche wants for it. The Vettes are lighter, much more powerful, have a nicer interior, and are more comfortable as an everyday driver (well the base Vette anyway).
November 16, 2007 7:02 pm
 pc pc
peccles, I would take either car but I think stock vettes are now equipped with 400hp engine. I have to disagree with you on the interior though. I've never been a fan of GM interiors. Porsche's on the other hand is immaculate, but ofcouse it comes with a much more hefty price tag.
November 16, 2007 9:59 pm
 carcrazy1234 carcrazy1234
i wouldn't mind either one... if i had the money to choose how ever (aka i could buy either one)... id definitely go for the 4S german quality cant be beat by american quality also, the engine sound of the porsche is just beautiful compared to the corvettes rugged harsh sounding engine
November 16, 2007 10:07 pm
No doubt the Porsche has a better interior than the Corvette. Its in line 6 no doubt is not as powerful as the Corvette's V8 in both the C6 and the Z08. Nevertheless for the around 80K the Z08 and the Carrera 4S is worth, its all a matter of what you look for in a car. Porsche and some GMs both have reputations for fit and finish, the former is more focused on better handling with power management/ delivery to all 4 wheels, the Corvette is just all about horsepower and speed (hence its slightly spartan interior). The corvette certainly looks more exotic as well but personally I'd go for the German ride.
November 17, 2007 12:04 am
 graham graham
Is'nt it a 3.8 in the S models?
November 17, 2007 6:48 pm
 jai_mav jai_mav
theres no doubt that both are great cars. what the porsche lacks in horsepower, it makes up in feedback and handling.
November 17, 2007 9:26 pm
 moyusuf moyusuf
Damn, I never keep track of Porsches.
November 17, 2007 11:46 pm
 puddingpuppet puddingpuppet
Let's all crap our pants because it's German.
November 18, 2007 9:33 am
 rydamee rydamee
the phrase every day car means you can drive it through snow banks, sleet, hail etc. being able to fit four adults and haul groceries while kickin supercar ass on california freeways, crowded or clear. now your answer would shift to the audi rs6. v10 twin turbo. you amg benz guys should hold your head in shame. no resale value.'04 cl65's are going for 45k!!! probably the greatest hot rod/daily driver ever. you can't find an '03 rs6 v8 twin turbo for that, which is a close 2nd to the cl65 as far as perfect everyday vehicle. facts gentlemen.
November 18, 2007 2:45 pm
 carolinaluvr101 carolinaluvr101
if i had to have a porsche 911, it would be the targa 4s because it looks prettier and has spectacular performance. but there are a lot of cars that can compete these days, such as the audi r8, noble m15, etc. i dont think the corvette can compete with the porsche 911, i mean its a great car, however, the porsche 911 is a superb car that doesnt just look great, but also drives great. and my choice for a corvette wouldnt be a z06, but probably an older model... and then if i bought an older car, i would buy a mercedes 280sl or jaguar e-type... not a corvette... :p
November 18, 2007 10:20 pm
 hondaboy22 hondaboy22
its the best car because its german.The corvette isn't even comparable, but because someone else commented on it, I have to say that the corvette seems to be an odd looking car with a very primitive interior.
November 19, 2007 2:14 am
 FOXHOUND FOXHOUND
lol, HI silversedanman!!!
November 20, 2007 6:20 pm
 kimbo-slice kimbo-slice
I agree that C4S is very good alternative to the Turbo. Yes, the Turbo is a supercar that you can use every single day, yes - it's faster, yes - it offers superior technology, but costs so much more and when it comes to the value for money C4S is simply better
November 28, 2007 6:14 pm